The 12th Victim

Eric Tiede

Charles Starkweather

Michael G. Larkin

Self

Jeff McArthur

Self

Phebe E. Bohart

Older Caril Ann Fugate

Hannah Hedrick

Velda Bartlett

Hannah Hedrick

Nurse

Jordan Monsell

Elmer Scheele

Ivy Votolato

Young Caril Ann Fugate

James McArthur

Self

Ryan Rohtla

Police Officer

Jim Rose

Radio Announcer

Michael Hogan

Radio Announcer

Scott Kay

Radio Announcer

Holgie Forrester

Mrs. Stockweather

Holgie Forrester

Mrs. Starkweather

Quinn Hemphill

Liza Ward

Jason Marrs

Charles Starkweather

McKay Stewart

Self - 2nd Lawyer

David Fyne

Self - John McArthur

Heywood McGuffee

Tommie Clair